Skip to main content
LHH Vietnam

Leadership Development

When should a manager coach, mentor or give direction?

A manager should coach when the person can work it out and needs help thinking, mentor when they need your experience to avoid a mistake you have already made, and give direction when the situation is urgent, risky or the person does not yet know what to do. Most managers direct by default because it is quick, and the skill is knowing which of the three the moment calls for.

The three modes

  • Coach: ask questions so the person finds their own answer and owns the decision
  • Mentor: share what you have learned, as one option for them to weigh
  • Direct: tell them what to do and why, when time, risk or a basic skill gap leaves no room to explore

A quick test

  • Does the person already know roughly what to do? Coach.
  • Do they lack the experience to see the options? Mentor.
  • Is it urgent, risky or a basic skill the person has not learned yet? Direct.
  • Does the person see the problem and want to act? If not, a different conversation has to come first.

Where managers get stuck

The common trap is directing by default. It feels faster, so the team stops thinking for itself and brings every problem back. The Manager as Coach Program teaches managers when to coach, when to mentor and when to simply give direction, and how to run a coaching conversation from start to finish.